What to Do If Your Neighbor Builds Over the Property Line

You step outside one morning, and there it is a new fence, shed, or structure that seems suspiciously close to your yard. Before panic sets in, take a breath. Property line disputes happen more often than you might think, and in most cases, they can be resolved peacefully and professionally.

I’m Rozi Dover, Associate Broker and REALTOR® here in Auburn and Opelika. Over the years, I’ve seen how small misunderstandings about property boundaries can cause unnecessary tension between neighbors. This guide will walk you through what to do (and what not to do) if your neighbor builds over your property line so you can protect your home, your investment, and your peace of mind.

How Property Line Disputes Happen

Most property line issues start innocently. A homeowner might install a fence without checking the survey, or a contractor may assume the edge of a lawn marks the true boundary. Over time, trees, landscaping, or even driveways can blur where one property ends and another begins.

In Auburn, where older neighborhoods and newer subdivisions often meet, property boundaries can shift slightly due to land grading or outdated surveys. That’s why confirming your exact boundary is the most important first step.

What Counts as Encroachment in Alabama?

An encroachment occurs when a person builds or places a structure like a fence, shed, driveway, or retaining wall on someone else’s property. Under Alabama law, encroachment can lead to both civil and legal disputes if not handled properly.

Encroachments are different from easements, which are legal rights that allow limited use of another’s land (for example, utility access or shared driveways). If you’re not sure whether an easement applies to your situation, it’s best to review your property deed or contact an attorney.

Step 1: Confirm the Boundary with a Professional Survey

Before assuming your neighbor has built over your property line, verify your boundaries. The most reliable way to do that is by hiring a licensed land surveyor. A professional survey:

Confirms the legal boundaries of your property
Identifies any encroachments or easements
Provides documentation you can use in discussions or legal proceedings

In Auburn and Opelika, surveyors are familiar with local plats and subdivision maps, so they can quickly clarify whether there’s been an overstep.

Step 2: Talk to Your Neighbor Calmly and Clearly

Once you have the survey results, the next step is communication — not confrontation. Most neighbors don’t intentionally build over property lines. A polite, factual conversation often solves the issue faster (and cheaper) than legal action.

Here’s a helpful approach:

Share the survey results and point out the discrepancy respectfully
Listen to your neighbor’s perspective — they may have acted on bad information
Suggest a reasonable solution, such as moving the fence or adjusting the layout

Keeping the tone calm and collaborative often preserves both your property rights and your neighborhood harmony.

Step 3: Gather Documentation and Take Photos

If the issue can’t be resolved verbally, start collecting evidence. Take dated photos of the encroachment, copies of your survey, and any written correspondence with your neighbor.

This documentation can be invaluable if you later need to involve your homeowners association (HOA), title company, or attorney. The goal is to show that you’ve made every reasonable effort to resolve the issue amicably before escalating.

Step 4: Know When to Involve a Title Company or Attorney

If your neighbor refuses to move the structure or disputes the survey, it may be time to consult a real estate attorney. They can:

Review your deed, title, and survey
Draft a boundary agreement or formal letter
Represent your interests in mediation or court, if necessary

In Auburn, many homeowners start by contacting a title company first, especially if the dispute involves unclear lot lines or historical plat errors. Title professionals can often locate older records and help determine the rightful property boundary.

Can You Sell Your Home with a Property Line Dispute?

Technically, yes — but it’s not ideal. Active disputes must be disclosed during a real estate transaction, which can make buyers nervous or delay closing. That’s why resolving any boundary issues before listing your home is crucial.

If you’re planning to sell soon, reach out to a REALTOR® familiar with Auburn’s property records and subdivision layouts (like me!). We can connect you with trusted surveyors, title experts, and attorneys to clear up the issue quickly.

How to Prevent Boundary Issues in the Future

Get a survey before making changes: Even small projects like fences or patios should start with accurate measurements.
Talk to your neighbors early: A simple heads-up before building near a boundary can prevent misunderstandings.
Keep records: Save surveys, permits, and receipts for any improvements near your property line.
Understand easements: These legal designations can affect how land is used and maintained.

A little preparation goes a long way toward protecting your property and maintaining good relationships in your neighborhood.

Final Thoughts: Protecting Your Property and Peace of Mind

Property line issues can feel stressful, but they don’t have to turn into major conflicts. With the right information, communication, and professional help, most encroachments can be resolved fairly and quickly.

Concerned about a property boundary issue in Auburn or Opelika? Contact me today for trusted local guidance and referrals to qualified surveyors and attorneys. Together, we’ll find the most effective and peaceful resolution.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do I know if my neighbor built over the property line?
A: Hire a licensed surveyor to confirm your exact boundary. They’ll provide documentation that shows whether there’s an encroachment.

Q: What should I do first if I think my neighbor encroached on my property?
A: Stay calm, get a survey, and talk to your neighbor before taking any legal steps.

Q: Can property lines be legally adjusted in Alabama?
A: Yes. Neighbors can agree to a boundary adjustment through a written easement or lot line agreement filed with the county.

Q: Should I contact my HOA or city before taking legal action?
A: Yes. Many subdivisions in Auburn have HOA rules that can help mediate or resolve fence and boundary disputes.

Q: Who pays for the property survey in a dispute?
A: Typically, the homeowner requesting the survey covers the cost, though some neighbors split the fee if both parties want verification.

Our Other Blogs

Sources

Posted by Rozi Dover on December 4th, 2025

Enjoy this blog post? Click here to subscribe for updates